What is the nature of possibility and necessity?
The nature of possibility and necessity is a complex philosophical topic that has been debated for centuries. There is no single answer that everyone agrees on, but here are some of the main perspectives:
Possibility
* Logical possibility: This is the broadest sense of possibility, encompassing anything that is not self-contradictory. For example, it is logically possible for a unicorn to exist, even though we know that unicorns do not exist in the real world.
* Metaphysical possibility: This is a narrower sense of possibility, which is restricted to what is possible within the laws of nature. For example, it is not metaphysically possible for a human to run faster than the speed of light.
* Epistemic possibility: This is the narrowest sense of possibility, which is limited to what we believe is possible based on our current knowledge. For example, before the discovery of the Americas, it was epistemically possible for Europeans to believe that the Earth was flat.
Necessity
* Logical necessity: This is the broadest sense of necessity, encompassing anything that is true in all possible worlds. For example, it is logically necessary that 2 + 2 = 4.
* Metaphysical necessity: This is a narrower sense of necessity, which is restricted to what is necessarily true within the laws of nature. For example, it is metaphysically necessary that every event has a cause.
* Epistemic necessity: This is the narrowest sense of necessity, which is limited to what we believe is necessarily true based on our current knowledge. For example, before the discovery of the Americas, it was epistemically necessary for Europeans to believe that the Earth was the center of the universe.
Relationship between possibility and necessity
There are different views on the relationship between possibility and necessity:
* Modal realism: This view holds that there are many possible worlds, and that each possible world is equally real. In this view, possibility is simply the property of being true in at least one possible world, and necessity is the property of being true in all possible worlds.
* Modal essentialism: This view holds that the essence of a thing determines its possibilities. For example, the essence of a triangle is to have three sides, so it is necessarily true that all triangles have three sides.
* Modal anti-realism: This view denies the existence of possible worlds and argues that possibility and necessity are merely concepts that we use to organize our thoughts about the world.
It is important to note that these are just a few of the many different views on the nature of possibility and necessity. There is no single answer that is universally accepted, and the debate continues to this day.